Current:Home > InvestMichigan’s top court throws out 2006 conviction linked to shaken baby syndrome -Capitatum
Michigan’s top court throws out 2006 conviction linked to shaken baby syndrome
View
Date:2025-04-12 11:39:27
DETROIT (AP) — The Michigan Supreme Court overturned a 2006 murder conviction in the death of an infant in an appeal that centered on new opinions about so-called shaken baby syndrome.
The court said Chazlee Lemons, who is serving a life prison sentence, deserves a new trial. Her lawyers have lined up scientific experts, and the doctor who performed the autopsy nearly 20 years ago changed his opinion on the manner of Nakita Lemons’ death.
It’s probable that a “jury would have a reasonable doubt” about Lemons’ guilt, the court said Thursday in a 5-2 decision led by Justice Megan Cavanagh.
Lemons was represented by the Innocence Clinic at University of Michigan Law School, which has successfully challenged similar convictions across the state.
An email seeking comment from the Wayne County prosecutor’s office wasn’t immediately answered Friday.
Nakita, who had experienced breathing problems since birth, was a few months old when she died while in Lemons’ care in 2005. The prosecutor charged the parent with first-degree murder, based on autopsy results and her statements to police.
Lemons told police that she shook Nakita three or four times to get her to stop crying, according to a summary of the case.
Dr. Bader Cassin, who performed the autopsy, said his examination revealed a swollen brain and retinal hemorrhages. At trial, he classified the death as shaken baby syndrome. Lemons’ lawyer at that time did not offer an expert to rebut Cassin.
But Cassin’s opinion changed in 2017 during an effort to reopen the case in Wayne County court. He said Nakita could have choked on baby formula. He noted that biomechanical scientists had demonstrated that the forces in shaking were insufficient to produce the injury.
The Innocence Clinic also offered experts, including a biomechanical engineer with experience researching head injuries. Prosecutors had their own experts to back up the shaken baby syndrome theory. A judge and the state appeals court ultimately upheld Lemons’ conviction.
The Supreme Court acknowledged that Lemons had made incriminating statements to police about shaking Nakita. But the court said a jury at a new trial might find that the confession was false.
“As we have recognized elsewhere, suspects presented with seemingly incontrovertible physical evidence of their guilt may confess falsely to ameliorate their current conditions,” the court said.
In dissent, Justice Brian Zahra accused the majority of relying on “extraordinarily suspect evidence” to rule in favor of Lemons and reverse the decisions of a prominent Detroit-area judge. Zahra said there wasn’t scientific evidence to believe the brain injuries were caused by choking on formula.
In a court filing, the American Academy of Pediatrics supported the prosecutor and had urged the Supreme Court not to be swayed by “fringe courtroom science” questioning head injuries.
___
Follow Ed White on X at https://twitter.com/edwritez
veryGood! (2)
Related
- 'Kraven the Hunter' spoilers! Let's dig into that twisty ending, supervillain reveal
- These Nordstrom Rack & Kate Spade Sales Are the Perfect Winter Pairing, Score Up to 78% Off
- Brothers elected mayors of neighboring New Jersey towns
- Who is the Super Bowl 58 halftime show performer? What to know about this year's show
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- 2 New Mexico Republican lawmakers seek to impeach Democratic governor over gun restrictions
- These Nordstrom Rack & Kate Spade Sales Are the Perfect Winter Pairing, Score Up to 78% Off
- The Best Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts For You and Your Boo
- Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
- Jamie Lee Curtis opens up about turning 65: 'I'm much less hard on myself'
Ranking
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- Ryan Gosling Shares How Eva Mendes Makes His Dreams Come True
- The 19 Best Hair Masks to Give Your Dry, Damaged Hair New Life
- Trinidad police are investigating a shooting that killed 3 people and wounded 5 others
- Retirement planning: 3 crucial moves everyone should make before 2025
- 'Work from anywhere' downside: potential double taxation from states. Here's what to know.
- Minnesota man freed after 25 years in prison files suit over wrongful conviction
- Poland’s parliament votes to lift immunity of far-right lawmaker who extinguished Hanukkah candles
Recommendation
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
Steely Dan, R.E.M., Timbaland, Hillary Lindsey and Dean Pitchford get into Songwriters Hall of Fame
2.7 million Zimbabweans need food aid as El Nino compounds a drought crisis, UN food program says
Lorne Michaels teases 'SNL' successor: 'It could easily be Tina Fey'
NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
Mila De Jesus' Husband Breaks Silence After Influencer’s Death
The Best Plus Size Workwear That’s Comfy and Cute— Nordstrom Rack, Amazon, Boohoo, SKIMS, and More
Smashing Pumpkins reviewing over 10,000 applications for guitarist role